I have a strong dislike of getting scared, but I do enjoy being disturbed

"There's a monster in the closet and it's gonna jump out at some point and I don't know when." Bad

yeah this is 100% where I am

I don't want to be startled or surprised

"This newspaper headline implies a world where people consider it normal for children to be thrown into something call 'the flensing pit' on a daily basis" good

I want clawing dread to hook itself slowly and inexorably into my brain

I hate hate hate it when there's a thing that Gets you!

yeah this is me 1000% too

boy do I love being disturbed!

I don't want to be Got!

The slow unfurling of a terrible tragedy caused by mundane human evil, delicious

(I'm still thinking about Mouthwashing, obviously)

same. big same.

I think you could hang with Signalis

there are technically surprise attacks from enemies here and there but on the whole the actual chased-by-monsters gameplay elements are some of the least scary in the business

but by the time you start really figuring out the story it feels like you're walking slowly towards a cliff edge

without the ability to stop

Ah. Obra Dinn

I recommend the movie La Llorona

Oh yeah this was the realization I had about myself as well

Being disturbed, feeling that sense of dread... atmosphere...