tl;dr is it's a solid war movie.... I do not know or care what chuds think, but despite the protag being a woman it does still cleave pretty closely to Tolkien esque lore. she is badass sure but she is not necessarily rewarded for it
I think the movie plays it pretty safe honestly.... it's a decent war movie in an LotR format with LotR esque themes but it doesn't do anything really unique
I'm not a huge fan of the human societies in Tolkien's lore but hell, even if you're a casual LotR fan it's good enough for the price of the movie ticket
also Miranda Otto narrates as Eowyn and they got Billy Boyd and Dominic Monaghan to do the voices of a couple of orcs that briefly show up.... both of which was really nice
wow and the cover art there kinda spoils the most badass moment of the movie LOL I'm glad I went into this one totally blind, I didn't even bother to look up what Tolkien had previously written about Hammerhand and his family