a book a week
6 years ago
Discussion post! For Junk Mage.
latest #53
dungeon fey
6 years ago
This was okay!! I am having trouble getting started thinking about it
dungeon fey
6 years ago
I don't regret having spent $1.50 and an hour or two with it but it also wasn't super memorable
dungeon fey
6 years ago
Much as I do like novellas and short stories there was a lot that could/should have been filled out to address its shortfalls I feel
立即下載
dungeon fey
6 years ago
Quill was the kind of fucko I find pretty easy to read about
dungeon fey
6 years ago
I found the antagonist distressingly one-dimensional lmao
dungeon fey
6 years ago
Also I pinged vikarmic on this already but I could pre-emptively Feel his disappointment at the lack of depth given to the technomanccy
dungeon fey
6 years ago
what! do you think! we are here for!!
Sword Logic
6 years ago
your feeling is correct
Sword Logic
6 years ago
this was light and sweet and had no particular depth, which is like, okay for a $1.50 airport read
Sword Logic
6 years ago
definitely disappointed by the lack of enemy necromancy though, they advertised it and didn't deliver
Sword Logic
6 years ago
making a shadowrun cyberzombie doesn't count
dungeon fey
6 years ago
hahaha
dungeon fey
6 years ago
I think reading this alongside of Simon Feximal I was a little bit like WHIPLASH
dungeon fey
6 years ago
(no spoilers for Feximal tho)
dungeon fey
6 years ago
Just like. Oh the different levels of style and depth you can add to writing, whew
Sword Logic
6 years ago
yeah this was definitely...not that....
MOVED
6 years ago
it was a fun and cute read! I definitely wanted more from it tho
MOVED
6 years ago
and yes the antagonist was very cut and dry
dungeon fey
6 years ago
I liked Quill's character arc tbh
dungeon fey
6 years ago
It was pretty standard like
dungeon fey
6 years ago
Fwippy selfish nerd learns it feels nice to help people
dungeon fey
6 years ago
He seemed pretty indignant about it
dungeon fey
6 years ago
But it's a trope for a reason haha
MOVED
6 years ago
yes!! I liked Hunter's too, just because I also like big soft buffs and learning to be people/selfish tropes
comfy drow cave
6 years ago
I read this on my lunch today! It was cute and fun. Very bite-sized entertainment.
comfy drow cave
6 years ago
The only thing that disturbed my suspension of disbelief is that he'd beg his stodgy boss FWB for help but not his parents he has a great relationship with, after starving and being threatened with guns
comfy drow cave
6 years ago
I was thrown out by that comparison but. Other than That, no other real problems.
comfy drow cave
6 years ago
Irresponsible slacker meets beefcake with a heart of gold is Good.
Shibepire
6 years ago
whups idk how I totally missed this, but yeah I agree with this plurk that it was very fluffy and clearly like. skimming a ton of details but also I wasn't expecting a lot given the length and price tag
Shibepire
6 years ago
there was a lot of stuff that felt like it was just slapped in for tropey empty calorie funtimes which I'm not against but also it just felt kind of loose and a little unpolished in that way
Shibepire
6 years ago
like I'm not gonna go write home about this, it's not groundbreaking in any way, I felt the urge to pick it apart in way too many places but overall it was enjoyable
dungeon fey
6 years ago
shibaface: I felt like it was a lil bit crying out for a good editor
Shibepire
6 years ago
yeaaah, definitely
Shibepire
6 years ago
especially towards the end I feel like the rising action just wound up weirdly aborted in several places that made it hard for me to really feel like the stakes were very high?
Shibepire
6 years ago
like the threat dissipated and reappeared with weird narrative beats wrt the confrontation with the necromancer lady
Shibepire
6 years ago
so like oh Quill has time to repair the gate, but whups she's back with a cyber suit! but he tangles her up and has time to repair his ship, but oh no now she's back! left it all with this sort of jerky start and stop feeling
Shibepire
6 years ago
I admit I kinda eyerolled a little at Junior too, since it was weirdly a little too convenient how he befriended this bone sucking horror monster, which meant the narls in general didn't feel like much of a threat
Shibepire
6 years ago
idk like I said, it was fun, but it could have been tightened up a lot
Shibepire
6 years ago
and yeah especially wedged between Feximal and Winterglass it's very different
dungeon fey
6 years ago
Yea for sure haha
dungeon fey
6 years ago
I'm actually really enjoying the variety of different stuff but sometimes it means like
dungeon fey
6 years ago
Remembering where the bar is very different
Shibepire
6 years ago
haha right
Shibepire
6 years ago
this lowered the bar
comfy drow cave
6 years ago
ia about the narrative stakes, the moment he was like?? cybersuit? WINDS ARMS TOGETHER I could turn her into a newt, it was like... why is there any tension after this
comfy drow cave
6 years ago
there can't be another sequcence where she's grabbed onto the ship because he could just rip her arms off and use that to patch up the rest
Shibepire
6 years ago
honestly now that you mention that I'm surprised that wasn't what he did
Shibepire
6 years ago
but yeah it seemed like every whiff of conflict just got snuffed so instantly that there was nothing to the story other than vaguely misfit guy frees buff amnesiac from captivity
Shibepire
6 years ago
I'm also a little disappointed that for a story of its length there was no boning
MOVED
6 years ago
insert joke here about the book being anti-climatic
dungeon fey
6 years ago
jhgfhjk
dungeon fey
6 years ago
whomp whomp
Shibepire
6 years ago
well played
back to top